Showing posts with label Harvard Business Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harvard Business Review. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Trivia experts – not just an oxymoron but a key to success

by Michael Arbow, MBA

Partner, RSD Solutions Inc.

www.RSDsolutions.com

info@RSDsolutions.com 

 

According to Vikram Mansharamani in a recent Harvard Business Review blog, the reign of the “expert” is over.  It has long been held (even by Harvard itself) that being a person who had gained “domain expertise” would enable you to have competitive advantage over those “generalist” out there who for whatever reason just couldn’t master one subject and had wide diverse fields of interest.  During the 20th century, experts ruled academia, finance, law and risk management to name a few.  This environment of deep study and thought is sadly (for them) becoming obsolete.  Why?  In order for the expert world to exist it relies heavily on a lack of connectivity – that is, what a worker does in rural China does not affect real estate prices in Kansas City.  This we are experiencing is no longer the case – events or changes in one area of study are effecting innumerable others.  To understand this and foresee this you need a generalist – someone who knows a little about a lot (like the fox).

 

Risk management departments are loaded with experts whose grasp on seemingly non-related events affecting their world has been called to question repeatedly in the past ten years – especially in the financial world.  The question then becomes, is your risk department designed for and living in the past’s non-connective world or has it moved onto being more insightful of how non-related developments will impact their organization’s risk profile.  Perhaps a question risk managers may wish to ask when interviewing future hires for this new environment is: “How often do you attend Trivia Night at the local pub?”  

 

For more on this follow the link to the HBR blog:  http://tinyurl.com/cc5fh89

Friday, March 4, 2011

The Judgment Deficit

by Rick Nason, PhD, CFA

Partner, RSD Solutions Inc.

www.rsdsolutions.com

info@rsdsolutions.com 

 

On my most recent plane trip I read a Harvard Business Review article by Amar Bhide that I have been meaning to read for some time.  The article is titled “The Judgment Deficit” (HBR, September 2010, pp 44 - 53).  

In this article, Bhide essentially points out that we have surrendered judgment to models and rule based thinking.  While he points out that there are times and situations where rules or models are appropriate, they can never capture the complexity and value of human judgment.  I wholeheartedly agree with him.  The article points out deficiencies in having computer models make lending decisions as well as other examples from the banking sector, but the surrender of human judgment to models (and even worse -  audits) is endemic throughout risk management – whether in the financial sector or not. 

As Bhide argues, it is time to get back to basics and get back to using human judgment.  A great judgment to start with is to read Amar Bhide’s article.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Face it

by Rick Nason, PhD, CFA

Partner, RSD Solutions Inc.

www.rsdsolutions.com

info@rsdsolutions.com

 

I was reading a very interesting Harvard Business Review article by Amar Bhide that I have been meaning to read for some time.  The article is titled “The Judgment Deficit” (HBR, September 2010, pp 44 - 53).  I will outline the article in my next blog as I believe it is an important article that has a lot of relevance for risk managers. 

The point I want to make in this blog is about a quote from futurist Paul Saffo that Bhide puts in his article.  The quote is: “Face it, innovation is an elite activity”.  What bull%$#^! was my first reaction.  And then I realized that we now depend on the almighty financial engineers and risk doctors (of which I am one) before we dare make a move.  Crap – he may be right was my second reaction.  Sad is how I currently feel.