Showing posts with label government debt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label government debt. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Sovereign Risk and Unintended Consequences

by Don Alexander, MBA

Associate, RSD Solutions Inc.

www.RSDsolutions.com

info@RSDsolutions.com

 

(Fiscal Monitor – Staying the Course on Fiscal Adjustment, IMF, June 2011) The IMF noted in its latest interim Fiscal Monitor that government actions to address budget deficits continue to make progress in the advanced economies – especially in core Europe, Australia and Canada.  This improvement is driven by recovering activity and higher revenues.

Despite the good news, there remains some doubt about debt sustainability and the political will to maintain austerity programs in countries like Greece.  Credit default spreads (CDS) are at new highs for Greece as investors worry about contagion.

Elsewhere, the US and Japan are slow to implement plans to control budget deficits and rising debt levels.  However, the US deficit for 2011 will be lower than earlier forecasts and similar to 2010 on a cyclically adjusted basis.  Policymakers urgently need to reach a consensus medium-term adjustment plan to avoid potential market distress.  Japan lacks a specific plan to address rising debt and contingent liabilities of an aging population.  There is a rising risk perception in peripheral Europe led by Greece, Ireland and Portugal followed by some concern about Spain.  Downward revisions for growth in Greece and Portugal have created more urgency. This underscores urgency for these countries to implement an adjustment program and develop a comprehensive and consistent approach for crisis management and adherence to Eurozone policies.  The record for emerging economies remains mixed as a number of countries are implementing fiscal consolidation at an appropriate pace.  In others, fiscal policy must be tightened quicker to avoid the potential risk of overheating.  Long-term, countries must implement policies to reduce imbalances and government market intervention.

The improvement in the outlook for government finances in a number of countries is overshadowed by recent events.  The surge in the CDS premiums for Greece raises a few questions – is the CDS exposure held by a few institutions or widely dispersed?  Can the institutions payout the billions required in a default?  Do we have concentrated risk such as AIG?  This is something that policymakers or regulators cannot answer.  

 

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Unquestioned Assumptions

By Stephen McPhie, CA

Partner, RSD Solutions Inc.

www.RSDsolutions.com

info@RSDsolutions.com 

 

Does your company revisit assumptions upon which your approach to risk is based?  Are assumptions challenged?  Is there a dynamic process to do this?  Throughout most of my career, U.S. government obligations have been considered to be the definitive risk free debt.  No longer, now that S&P has placed it on negative outlook.  Willem Buiter, a former member of the Monetary Policy Committee and now chief economist at Citigroup, told the CFA Institute annual conference in Edinburgh[1]: “S&P’s negative outlook (on the US) is likely to be followed by a negative watch and then a downgrade early in 2013, unless a miracle happens …”.

 

Should this have been foreseen some time ago?  I would argue that this assumption about U.S. government debt should have been questioned several years ago.  In fact, perhaps it should never have been taken as an assumption. 

 

Nothing is risk free and no assumptions are valid beyond the moment they are made.  That is why a risk management system must be dynamic, and not imposed statically and left to apply until someone new comes in and decides to do an update, perhaps years later.



[1] As reported in the Herald www.heraldscotland.com/business/markets-economy/us-economy-may-face-debt-downgrade-1.1100695